Why Reference Won't Teach You to Draw From Imagination


Greetings Artisan!

One of the most common questions I get is: "How do I draw without reference?"

I notice a lot of artists get stuck with this. The two major patterns I tend to see are:

1. Artists who want to draw without reference but aren't sure how to make their work feel solid and authentic. They know they need to reference the world, need to understand anatomy. Reference is going to be one of the major sources for understanding the world... but they're not quite sure how to use it.

2. Artists who already draw with reference as their major way of creating ... from photos, from life, or even just from copying other people's art. These artists are often stuck or handcuffed to the reference. They need to have it there or they really can't draw at all.

There's a big misconception that if you draw from reference and practice long enough, eventually you'll just be able to draw without it.

I made a video about this, where I break down how I see this working from my own experience and from teaching hundreds of students to draw from imagination:

You can Check it Out Here:


Watch "Why Reference Won't Teach You to Draw From Imagination"

video preview

It's worth talking about what drawing from imagination actually means, because a lot of people have very different ideas about this.

One of the things I point out in the video is that there are many ways to make art and almost all of them are totally valid.

Some of my favourite artists, like Robert McGinnis, create art with heavy photo reference (often tracing onto the canvas).

Other artists, like James Gurney (of Dinotopia fame), have a heavy reliance on the photographs he shoots and the physical maquettes he builds.

This harkens back to some of the best illustrators who have used heavy photographic and physical reference. A lot of the classic science fiction book cover artists would make spaceships out of water bottles combined with bits of paper and photograph them.

But personally, I always liked the idea of just drawing from imagination with nothing at my side.

So this is the skill I built.

There's a spectrum here though. Even artists who primarily make things up in their head will often include mood boards, reference boards, anatomy books as part of their process.

So how does this actually work?

The critical thing to understand is that "practice makes permanent." You get better at doing the things you actually do.

In The Book of Five Rings, Miyamoto Musashi famously said: "You can only fight the way you train." I think this is critical to understand for all human endeavours.

If you want to draw from imagination, you have to practice drawing from imagination. And understand exactly where reference fits into your process.

A big part of this for me is building visual library. I do a lot of sketching. I mess around and I make a lot of mistakes, even when I'm drawing professional illustrations.

Part of those mistakes and sketches is me understanding in my mind how to draw these things. The more I do it and the better I get, the less I need to make mistakes.

One of the things I teach in the Line and Colour Academy is the five-minute reference grab.

Once I've sketched out my drawing and figured out a good thumbnail, I do a five-minute Google or Pinterest search to grab reference for the key things I need. Animal reference. What a saddle actually looks like. A couple of photos of a particular type of tree.

Just make sure if I do need reference, it doesn't suck up a lot of time finding it.

A lot of artists love building a mood board before they get started. It really is just a matter of how you like to work.

But if you want to draw from imagination, you've got to practice drawing from imagination.

If you want a more in-depth take, check out the video.

Otherwise... remember:

  • Practice makes Permanent.
  • You can only fight the way you train.

-Tim

PS: I'm going to run the 8 week Line and Colour Intensive again in mid-April. I'll send out an announcement email so you can sign up to hear more soon.

PPS: The first run of the Intensive actually went really well. I'm making a bunch of changes to make it even better. It was interesting to see that a lot of people had a really challenging time drawing 20 thumbnails. And that many artists, despite being quite skilled, hadn't fully developed their construction phase. Some of the results we got at the end were really amazing.

The Drawing Codex Newsletter

Each week I share art tips and advice, along with extra details and images from my Youtube Videos. There are some things (like showing static images!) that old-school text and email is really good at. This newsletter adds a whole new level to The Drawing Codex experience!

Read more from The Drawing Codex Newsletter

Greetings Artisan! Artists frequently get told that they need to learn highly detailed rendering. Often the goal is fully realistic anatomy, rendered with perfect lighting and detail... And while this works for some... The reality is many artists are actually aspiring to create simpler artwork with cartoony style.I don't know about you... but for me this was a major part of my artistic journey. I spent a lot of time learning to render. I also spent a lot of time teaching people rendering and...

video preview

Greetings Artisan!I hope you had a great holiday break... I don't know about you... but creating covers was always one of my 'art goals' when I started out.The cover art on fantasy books I read as a kid was probably one of my main inspirations to become an artist. And when I was trying to break into comics, the idea of being good enough to get paid to create a cover seemed like the ultimate goal. This is what the 'best' artists did. A great cover (or poster) combines the story of the book,...

Greetings Artisan! Let’s dive into some structural drawing… Drawing heads and faces is probably one of the most important things to do as an artist. It helps you connect with viewers, and a lot of us start our drawing journey drawing simple faces. You have probably heard of the many different structural methods for drawing faces and heads. You have probably heard of the “Loomis Method”. But something I have found over the years, is that despite many aspiring artists and students learning...